Where we agreed
6 numeric ballots landed at a 3.92 average. Population SD: 0.73.
January 2026 selection
3.9/5
- Published
- 2022
- Genre
- Literary fiction, coming-of-age
- Length
- 560 pages
- Participation
- 6 finished · 2 DNR records
Book brief
The bio
Set in the mountains of southern Appalachia, the novel follows a sharp, funny boy nicknamed Demon as he survives foster care, poverty, addiction, love, and loss in a modern reworking of David Copperfield.
Published club synthesis
Club verdict
An emotionally bruising, ambitious read the club respected more than it loved.
The book club’s experience with Demon Copperhead was defined by a respect for Kingsolver’s character-building, though the "slog" of the middle chapters divided the group. While the higher-rated reviews (Matt, Nathan, and Ed) highlighted the emotional resonance and the power of the protagonist’s voice, a significant portion of the club struggled with the relentless "torture porn" aspects and the pacing of the Appalachian setting. Some members found the cultural specifics, like the obsession with high school football, to be a hurdle, and others noted that the narrative voice occasionally felt too mature for the character’s age. Ultimately, the club viewed the novel as a powerful, visceral achievement in storytelling that—while deeply moving—could have benefitted from a more concise edit and a less grueling middle act.
The scorecard
Where we agreed. Where we fought.
Where we fought
Matt went highest at 5/5; Eric went lowest at 3/5. Range: 2.0 stars.
8 preserved records
Member ballots
Open any ballot. Direct historical wording remains untouched.
MattMatt gave the book a perfect score, clearly connecting deeply with Kingsolver’s modern Dickensian epic.5/5
Matt gave the book a perfect score, clearly connecting deeply with Kingsolver’s modern Dickensian epic.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
NathanNathan found the journey incredibly moving and had a strong visceral reaction to the plot's cruelty, though he had minor questions regarding the central romance.4.5/5
Nathan found the journey incredibly moving and had a strong visceral reaction to the plot's cruelty, though he had minor questions regarding the central romance.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
EdEd praised the immersive character voices and the satisfying ending, despite finding the American high school football culture "cringe" and the framing device slightly cliché.4/5
Ed praised the immersive character voices and the satisfying ending, despite finding the American high school football culture "cringe" and the framing device slightly cliché.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
JoshJosh enjoyed the experience overall but felt the narrative momentum faltered during a weaker middle section.4/5
Josh enjoyed the experience overall but felt the narrative momentum faltered during a weaker middle section.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
AlecAlec felt the book veered into "torture porn" and noted a disconnect between the writing style and the character's age, finding the middle a significant drag.3/5
Alec felt the book veered into "torture porn" and noted a disconnect between the writing style and the character's age, finding the middle a significant drag.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
EricEric agreed that the book was overlong and repetitive, expressing a wish that it had delved further into the racial dynamics of the region.3/5
Eric agreed that the book was overlong and repetitive, expressing a wish that it had delved further into the racial dynamics of the region.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
JacobJacob was unable to connect with the story enough to reach the finish line.DNR
Jacob was unable to connect with the story enough to reach the finish line.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
OliverOliver sat this one out entirely.DNR
Oliver sat this one out entirely.
No questionnaire answers were recorded for this historical ballot.
No ballots are on the live record yet. Be the first one to put a verdict on the wall.