she club on my

BOOK RATINGS

til i ed
One continuous feed from the highest-rated reads to the lowest.
Hall of Fame — Top Three
🥇 #1
Demon Copperhead cover
Demon Copperhead
Barbara Kingsolver
"Current best of 2026."
Chooser
AL
Alec
Group Verdict
3.9
Strong
🥈 #2
Peter and Wendy cover
Peter and Wendy
J.M. Barrie
"Wonder, melancholy, and a lot of baggage."
Chooser
JA
Jacob
Group Verdict
3.8
Strong
🥉 #3
Between Two Fires cover
Between Two Fires
Christopher Buehlman
Chooser
ER
Eric
Group Verdict
3.6
Strong
#5
Dragonflight cover
Dragonflight
Anne McCaffrey
Chooser
JO
Josh
Group Verdict
3.1
Mixed
#6
A Confession cover
A Confession
Leo Tolstoy
"Raw crisis, wobblier resolution."
Chooser
MA
Matt
Group Verdict
3.0
Mixed
UP NEXT
The Gone World cover
The Gone World
Tom Sweterlitsch
Nathan's July selection.
Chooser
NA
Nathan
Group Verdict
TBD
July
Hall of Shame — Bottom Three
💀 LOWEST
A Confession cover
A Confession
Leo Tolstoy
The June crisis lands lowest so far, but exactly in the middle.
Chooser
MA
Matt
Group Verdict
3.0
Mixed
🗑️ NEXT
Dragonflight cover
Dragonflight
Anne McCaffrey
Chooser
JO
Josh
Group Verdict
3.1
Mixed